What sold in Burton Hill, and what did it actually sell for?
Twenty-three single-family homes closed in the Sunset Acres and Valley Acres core of Burton Hill between 16 October 2025 and 14 September 2026, at a median of $365,000, about $221 per square foot, 1,680 square feet, built 1956, on a 0.172-acre lot, going under contract in a median 32 days at 97.4% of the original asking price. That is a small sample, and the median is the least useful number in it. Nine of those closings were built between 1954 and 1956, measured 1,273 to 1,408 square feet, and sat on nearly the same lot — and they sold from $215,000 to $390,000, a range of $175,000 on houses that match on paper.
By Eric Duran, The Fort Real Estate | 17 November 2026
Most neighborhood market reports work because the housing stock varies: split the sales by vintage or size and a pattern falls out. Burton Hill does not cooperate, and that is what makes it worth reading.
In this twelve months, 21 of the 23 closings were built between 1950 and 1958. Ten sat on exactly 0.172 acres and fourteen on either 0.172 or 0.144. Nineteen had two bathrooms, sixteen had three bedrooms, and not one had a pool. Six streets account for every sale but two.
So every field a tax record, an automated estimate, or a neighbor doing quick math can actually read — year built, square footage, lot size, bedroom and bathroom count — is close to constant here. And the price per square foot still ran from $153 to $287. It nearly doubled with none of those variables moving. Seven of the 23 closed at or above their opening asking price; five closed below 86% of it.
Figures are from NTREIS, pulled 14 October 2026, and cover MLS activity only. Sample sizes are stated throughout.
Nine houses that match on paper, $175,000 apart
Narrow the 23 closings to the tightest group in the data — built 1954 to 1956, 1,250 to 1,450 square feet, eight of the nine on a lot between 0.144 and 0.200 acres, no pools — and you get nine sales. Here is the whole spread, per square foot:
- $153, $179, $180, $189 — the bottom four
- $250, $260, $262, $275, $287 — the top five
There is almost nothing in the middle. The cheapest of the nine was a 1956 house of about 1,400 square feet that closed at $215,000. The most expensive was a 1956 house of about 1,360 square feet — 40 square feet smaller — that closed at $390,000.
Now run the arithmetic a seller actually does. Apply the neighborhood’s own median of $221.31 per square foot to those two houses:
- The 1,402-square-foot house prices out at $310,277. It sold for $215,000 — the formula is 44% too high.
- The 1,361-square-foot house prices out at $301,203. It sold for $390,000 — the formula is 23% too low.
One neighborhood median, two houses 41 square feet apart, missing in opposite directions by a combined 67 points. Price per foot is a screening number here, not a valuation method, and on this stock it barely screens.
What the MLS record cannot show you is the part doing all the work: condition, what has been updated and when, how the floor plan reads, and where the opening price landed. One sequence in the data makes the point without any inference. A 1956 house of about 1,400 square feet closed in October 2025 at $215,000 — the lowest price per foot in the dataset. The same address came back to market this year at roughly 1,806 square feet, about 400 more than it had, asking $459,900. The lot did not change. The year built did not change. Everything that set the price did.
So the adjustment work matters more than the comp list. Condition grades and the measurement standard behind a square-footage figure carry the weight in a neighborhood like this, and they are what an automated estimate cannot see. Texas is also a non-disclosure state, so sale prices are not public record here, which is why online estimates run wider than in states that publish closings. The four different numbers that all get called your home’s value are worth separating before you anchor on one.
Where the line is drawn moves the median $25,000
A warning if you are pulling your own comparables here: the MLS map area commonly drawn over Burton Hill straddles the Fort Worth and Westworth Village city line and takes in three different sub-markets.
Pull the whole polygon and you get 45 closed single-family sales at a median of $390,000. Pull the Sunset Acres and Valley Acres core — the figures this post and the Burton Hill neighborhood page report — and you get 23 at $365,000. One subdivision on the northern edge accounts for 17 of the 22-sale difference.
Both numbers are correct; they describe different places. If a report hands you a Burton Hill median without saying where the boundary sits, you cannot tell which one you are holding, and $25,000 of median rides on the answer.
A fifth never sold, and the condos are a separate market
Of the 28 distinct single-family properties that went to market here and reached a conclusion, five never closed — 17.9%. Count listings instead of properties and you would say 28.1%, because two were listed, withdrawn, and listed again. The lower figure is the honest one — worth remembering whenever you are quoted a failure rate.
Price was not obviously the problem. Those five got their final asking prices down to a median $212 per square foot — below the $221 the 23 closings achieved — having opened at essentially the market’s achieved number. Three of the five reduced at least once, and they came off after a median 110 cumulative days. One, a 1954 house of about 1,200 square feet, cut from $304,900 to $214,900 over 373 days and still did not sell.
We will not name a cause the MLS record cannot carry. River Oaks produced the same result on a larger sample, and the lesson holds here: when the price is already defensible and the house still is not selling, another reduction is probably the wrong tool.
The condominiums on the edge of this area are a different market, reported separately and never blended into the single-family median. Twelve closed at a median $210,000, about $159 per square foot, built 1970, in a median 50 days at 95.4% of ask. Their failure rate is 45.5% — ten of 22 distinct properties — against 17.9% for the houses. Two product types on the same few streets, and not comparables for each other in either direction.
One more thing if you are watching listings here. Eight were active or pending at the pull, asking a median $327,450 — below the $365,000 closed median, which looks like softening until you divide. Per foot they want $226 against the $221 that closed: smaller houses asking more, after a median 64 days, five of eight already reduced. Standing inventory is a biased sample, not a comp set.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the median home price in Burton Hill?
Twenty-three single-family homes in the Sunset Acres and Valley Acres core closed at a median of $365,000 between October 2025 and September 2026, per NTREIS data pulled 14 October 2026. Draw the boundary wider and the median rises to $390,000 across 45 sales, so any Burton Hill median needs its scope stated with it.
Why is the price per square foot so inconsistent in Burton Hill?
Because the houses are nearly interchangeable on paper, so none of the recorded variables explain the price. Over twelve months the per-foot figure ran from $153 to $287 on 1950s houses of similar size on similar lots. Condition, updates, floor plan, and the opening price are doing the work, and none of those appear in a tax record or an automated estimate.
Can I use the neighborhood’s price per square foot to value my Burton Hill house?
Not reliably. Applying the $221.31 median to two 1956 houses 41 square feet apart overprices one by 44% and underprices the other by 23%. Price per foot narrows a list of comparables; it does not set a number. A comparative market analysis adjusts for condition and features, and it is not an appraisal.
How many Burton Hill listings fail to sell?
Five of 28 distinct single-family properties that reached a conclusion never closed, which is 17.9%. The condominiums nearby ran at 45.5%, ten of 22. Counting listings rather than properties inflates the figure to 28.1%, because a relisted home gets counted twice.
Does a price reduction fix a stalled listing in Burton Hill?
Not on this evidence. The five that never sold had already reduced to a median $212 per square foot, below the $221 the closings achieved, and still came off after a median 110 cumulative days. That points at something other than price, worth diagnosing before cutting again.
Burton Hill is a neighborhood where the comparable that looks identical to yours probably is not, and where the median describes almost none of the houses in it. That cuts both ways: an online estimate can land well under what an updated house here will bring, and well over what an original one will. If you want to know which side of that spread you are on, send me a text and we will go through the actual comparables, or call 817-703-1333.
About Eric Duran
Eric Duran is the founder and Realtor behind The Fort Real Estate, a boutique brokerage in Fort Worth, Texas. A former firefighter and paramedic, he’s guided buyers and sellers across West Fort Worth since 2020 — from TCU, Colonial, and Tanglewood to Ridglea, Arlington Heights, and the new builds out in Aledo. He has been recognized as a Fort Worth Real Producers Top Agent in 2025 and 2026, a list ranked by yearly MLS sales volume and limited to the top 1,000 agents in the market, and was featured in the magazine as an “Agent on the Rise” in May 2025. Reach Eric at 817-703-1333 or thefortre.com.
Market figures are from NTREIS, pulled 14 October 2026, covering MLS-reported activity in the Sunset Acres and Valley Acres core of Burton Hill (76114). Eric Duran is a Realtor, not an appraiser, attorney, inspector, or tax professional; a comparative market analysis is not an appraisal.